Select Comments From Thrutch

This page shows a selection of comments made at Thrutch. At the moment it is updated manually, so to be sure to see the latest comments, or to comment on a comment, please go directly to: amitghate.blogspot.com

Saturday, March 18, 2006

I just finished reading your 'All for One' article and I loved it!

It was perfect, I only wish we had leaders that would say some of the things you said.

One of your last paragraphs really caught my attention though:

"For if we fail to reverse our pattern, men will continue to learn that their rights are a sham, that the government’s promise to protect the individual is a hoax, and that only by refraining from thinking and speaking out might they be momentarily safe. Men will then go on to realize that they must seek out true protectors, in the form of some gang; ethnic, religious or otherwise; who may afford them a measure of security, albeit at the cost of complete obedience. Eventually the gangs will fight it out in an effort to wrest absolute power and to subjugate the others."


It reminded me of an article called 'The Fate of the State' by MARTIN VAN CREVELD.

I highly recommend it; it talks about the failure of the state and people turning to non-state forces (clans, gangs, tribes) to do what the state used to do.

I don’t agree with all the premises or conclusions, but it’s an interesting read.

--
Posted by Apollo to Thrutch at 3/18/2006 07:23:23 PM